Willow Crier is at it again! As chairwoman for Turtle's annual Ice Cream Festival, she is unable to enter the town's sponsored ice cream making contest. So, she does what any good cook-off addict does, she talks her daughter into entering. As the festival is just getting heated up, the towns local writer in residence turns up frozen, sitting on a bucket of Pistachio Goodness in the walk-in freezer. After being accused of being a "peeping" Tom, breaking and entering, and impersonating a police officer, Willow does her darndest to find the elusive killer plaguing her town. Getting into the town's good graces wasn't easy and she sure wants to stay there!