Considering the volatile, sometimes contradictory sounds and impulses
...And You Will Know Us by the Trail of Dead
bring together in their music, it's remarkable that the band's track record is so consistent. However, on
IX
, their extremes meet in the middle in a way that often feels too balanced. The group's ninth album -- named not for its place in
Trail of Dead
's discography, but for a planet in Frank Herbert's Dune series -- doesn't aim to re-create the fervor of
The Century of Self
,
Tao of the Dead
, or
Lost Songs
. Instead,
Conrad Keely
Jason Reece
, and company opt for a more introspective outlook, but even their personal crises are on a grand scale, taking on biblical proportions on "Jaded Apostles" and riffing on
Sigmund Freud
's The Ego and the Id on "The Lie Without a Liar." Songs such as these and the blustery breakup lament "The Ghost Within" give
's first half a similar tempo and emotional tenor that border on monotony; fortunately, touches like the formidable percussion on "A Million Random Digits" and the quintessentially
gallop of "The Doomsday Book" make things a little more distinctive. While the album's second half delivers the peaks and valleys more familiar to the band's sound, the overall effect is still somewhat muted. "The Dragonfly Queen" turns
's midtempo churn into a strength, delivering dark, jangly pop that feels better suited to the album's emotions; later, "Bus Lines" provides a similar intimacy despite its substantial length. Lavish instrumentals like "How to Avoid Huge Ships" counterbalance the intensity of "Lost in the Grand Scheme," and while both sides are well executed, neither makes as much of an impact as it has in the past. It may not be
's most exciting album, but there are still enough bright moments here to keep fans engaged. ~ Heather Phares