Criminal defense attorney, Emily Hall, is in a rut. She just lost a big case, she can't remember the last time she went on a date, and her only friends are her older sister and her pet tortoise, Leo. It looked like she was going to be spending another Valentine's Day alone this year, until her sister talked her into testing out her new dating app. To her surprise, the app paired her up with her old high school rival! Could it get any worse? Bestselling sci-fi author, Nolan Peters, just lost the love of his life. After planning a very romantic proposal, he got turned down. Now he's stuck on the happily ever after that could have been. His friends think he needs to move on. Maybe they're right. Valentine's Day is coming up, and who wants to spend it alone? When he signs up for the app, he never, in a million years, expected it to pair him up with the snobby Emily Hall from high school. Now that fate has brought them back together, can they look past their history and find love where they least expected it?