Taking a cue from the old
Blondie
marketing slogan, the sophomore effort from
Dave Grohl'
s post-
Nirvana
band was their "The Foo Fighters is a band" project -- well, at least it was intended that way, but
Grohl
pushed aside drummer
William Goldsmith
during the recording and played on the entire record. And who could blame him? When you're the greatest drummer in rock, it's hard to sit aside for someone else, no matter how good your intentions, and
Grohl'
s drumming does give the
Foos
muscle underneath their glossy exterior. That slickness arrives via producer
Gil Norton
, hired based on his work with
the Pixies
, but he manages to give
The Colour and the Shape
almost too sleek a sheen, something that comes as a shock after the raggedness of the group's debut. Even the glossy final mix of
Nevermind
has nothing on the unapologetic arena rock of
-- it's all polished thunder, rock & roll that's about precision not abandon. Some may miss that raw aggression of
s earlier work, but he's such a strong craftsman and musician that such exactness also suits him, highlighting his sense of melody and melodrama, elements abundantly in display on the album's two biggest hits, the brooding midtempo rockers
"My Hero"
and
"Everlong."
Elsewhere, the
grind out three-chord rockers with an aplomb that almost disguises just how slick
Norton
's production is, but everything here, from the powerful rush of the band to the big hooks and sleek surface, wound up defining the sound of post-grunge modern rock, and it remains as perhaps the best example of its kind. [
Legacy
's tenth anniversary edition of
was expanded by six bonus tracks, adding a clutch of non-LP B-sides, the highlight of which is a version of
Gerry Rafferty'
s
"Baker Street."
] ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine