The Hurting
would have been a daring debut for a
pop
-oriented band in any era, but it was an unexpected success in England in 1983, mostly by virtue of its makers' ability to package an unpleasant subject -- the psychologically wretched family histories of
Roland Orzabal
and
Curt Smith
-- in an attractive and sellable musical format. Not that there weren't a few predecessors, most obviously
John Lennon
's
Plastic Ono Band
album -- which was also, not coincidentally, inspired by the work of primal scream pioneer
Arthur Janov
. (But
Lennon
had the advantage of being an ex-
Beatle
when that meant the equivalent to having a box next to God's in the great arena of life, where
Tears for Fears
were just starting out.) Decades later,
"Pale Shelter,"
"Ideas as Opiates,"
"Memories Fade,"
"Suffer the Children,"
"Watch Me Bleed,"
"Change,"
"Start of the Breakdown"
are powerful pieces of music, beautifully executed in an almost minimalist style.
"Memories Fade"
offers emotional resonances reminiscent of
"Working Class Hero,"
while
"Pale Shelter"
functions on a wholly different level, an exquisite sonic painting sweeping the listener up in layers of pulsing synthesizers, acoustic guitar arpeggios, and sheets of electronic sound (and anticipating the sonic texture, if not the precise sound of their international breakthrough
hit
"Everybody Wants to Rule the World"
). The work is sometimes uncomfortably personal, but musically compelling enough to bring it back across the decades. ~ Bruce Eder