Barbara Cook
confesses at the outset of this live recording, made in June 2011 at Feinstein's at the Regency in New York, that she has run out of ideas for themes for her nightclub sets and this time has just picked a batch of good songs she's never sung before. This isn't quite true, but it is understandable that
Cook
wouldn't want to state the show's theme specifically since, as the title
You Make Me Feel So Young
suggests, that theme concerns aging, and the perpetually young singer is 83. But why should she acknowledge that if she doesn't feel it or, especially, sound like it?
's voice is remarkably intact on these songs, whether she is intoning the long lines of a sad ballad like "I'm a Fool to Want You" or bouncing along to the lively rhythms of the opener, "Are You Havin' Any Fun?" But that song states the evening's throughline when the singer reminds her listeners, "You aren't gonna live forever." Other songs, such as
Alan Jay Lerner
and
Burton Lane
's "Wait 'Til You're Sixty-Five" and "Here's to Life" also explore the matter of seniority, and even when the point is not made in so many words, it often is by implication, as in "What Did I Have That I Don't Have?," another
Lerner
/
Lane
composition.
makes a point of dedicating
Stephen Sondheim
's "Live Alone and Like It" to her divorced listeners, including herself in the category. It's true that not every song is about the concerns of getting and being old, but those that aren't tend to be change-of-pace palate clearers like
Nat King Cole
's "The Frim Fram Sauce," for which
breaks out a kazoo and does a solo. Even before then, her backup band has given much of the music a 1920s hot jazz feel, especially in the woodwind work of
Steve Kenyon
. Musical director
Lee Musiker
, meanwhile, has his own fast solo in "This Can't Be Love." The entire band gets a workout on a closing version of "I Got Rhythm" that might be called "The 'I Got Rhythm' Variations." As a coda,
reasonably looks to a hopeful future with a songwriter outside her usual realm, turning in a precise and unadorned version of
John Lennon
's "Imagine" over
Musiker
's piano. It shows that, at whatever age one may be, idealism is still possible. ~ William Ruhlmann