When
Acetone
released their debut album,
Cindy
, in 1993, the band seemed to run on two speeds -- nearly all of their songs were either semi-grunge numbers with loud distorted guitars and a fairly heavy stomp, or slowcore-influenced tunes that suggested their favorite
Velvet Underground
song was "Candy Says." While some
Neil Young
-style country accents and pop overtones would later find their way into the mix, this duality remained common throughout
's recording career, though the slowcore side of their personality was getting a lot more play on their swan song, 2000's
York Blvd
.
folded after the death of bassist
Richie Lee
in 2001, and 16 years later,
Light in the Attic
paid tribute to the band with a career-spanning collection,
1992-2001
, that combines material from their albums with previously unreleased demos and home recordings from the band's archive. The set pares down their duality and focuses exclusively on the slowcore side of their personality; if this album was all a curious listener had to go on, they'd never even know that numbers like "Pinch," "Final Say," "It's a Lie," or their cover of
Kris Kristofferson
's "Border Lord" had any place in the group's aesthetic. Given that
's following was modest during their lifetime and they're not especially well remembered today, this is a serious flaw, as this set gives an ultimately inaccurate portrait of their body of work, ignoring an important facet of their sound. That said, as a summary of
's slowcore-influenced material,
is splendid. While most slowcore bands tended to sound sad and downbeat, there was a sunny side to
's most languid music, and the subtle virtuosity of
Mark Lightcap
's guitar was a perfect foil for the purposeful drift of
Lee
's bass and
Steve Hadley
's drums. And while most of the unreleased material doesn't stand out from the album cuts, that also means they're on par with the stuff the group released back in the day, and what's here is quietly magical at its best. If
were to release a companion volume of
's noisier stuff, then
would make a bit more sense; as it is, this collection is full of fine music that merits attention, but as a career summary, it falls short of the mark. ~ Mark Deming