Now in its second season in our stores, Trader Joe’s Dill Pickle Mustard couples the savory versatility of mustard with the snappy, herbaceous kick of a well-dilled pickle, via the addition of natural pickle flavoring, dill weed, and actual diced-up pickle pieces. The amalgam of these elements yields a superbly summer-y sauce, if there ever was one.

Made for us by a fifth-generation mustard maker, this Dill Pickle Mustard is an obvious must-have for burgers, hot dogs, and sandwiches—it’s a natural for beach outings, backyard barbecues, and picnics in the park. We ought to also mention its usefulness in making marinades, deviled eggs, and especially delicious potato salad—give it a go with your favorite potatoes and you’ll see exactly what we mean.