Even though successfully revitalized , it didn't become a huge hit, which was a disappointment, considering that the band adjusted their sound to fit the times. Taking that into account, set out to make a classic album with 's successor, . And, surprisingly, that's exactly what they've delivered. From the outset, it's clear that finds the band returning to the glam-inflected, unabashedly catchy, arena-ready pop-metal that made them stars -- and it's also clear that they're not concerned with having a hit, they just want to make a good record. For them, that means returning to the pop-metal formula that made and blockbusters, even if they must know that this signature sound no longer guarantees a hit at the close of the '90s. It is true that this approach means sounds out of time in 1999, but it's a tight, attractive album with more than its share of big hooks, strong riffs, and memorable melodies. There are a couple of slow moments here and there, but no more than those on , and the best songs (particularly the opening triptych of plus the jangly -esque ) are worthy additions to an already strong catalog. But what's best about is that it's utterly not self-conscious. feels free to try straight pop, appropriate riffs, or play straight metal, without caring whether it's hip or commercial. That doesn't mean is a classic, but it does mean that it's their most appealing effort in over a decade. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine