Every now and then, we introduce a product that attains a kind of instantaneous iconic status. Our Everything But the Bagel Sesame Seasoning Blend definitely falls into that category. Since its debut back in 2017, it has remained perennially popular, and it’s easy to see why: it turns out that garlic, onion, poppy, sesame, and sea salt synergize with a whole lot more than just bagels. Take, for instance, this new addition to our cheese section, Trader Joe’s Everything But the Bagel Cheddar Cheese. It’s crafted just for us by an expert cheesemaker, who infuses each wheel with the very same seasoning we sell on our shelves, so that each bite is rich with the maximalist mix of aromatic alliums, crunchy seeds, and savory spice you know and love.

In addition to making an excellent cheese to simply snack upon, we find that these pops of flavor and texture also make this bold and tangy Cheddar a great choice for a grilled cheese or macaroni bake, or slicing and serving atop a nice burger on a Brioche Bun. Try it on your next cheese board or charcuterie spread the next time you have company over. And if you feel like bringing everything full circle, try melting a slice over a toasted bagel with a fried egg and bacon for an unbeatable breakfast sandwich.