With their classic early lineup, anchored by the swagger, grit, and heart of lead singer
Ronnie Van Zant
,
Lynyrd Skynyrd
merged
Allman Brothers
guitars with barrelhouse piano (courtesy of keyboardist
Billy Powell
, a bigger part of
Skynyrd
's classic sound than most people realize), then tossed in a big dose of
hard rock
attitude and gave it all credence with a kind of blustering and cocky
honky tonk
sensibility. The original band just sounded so, well, right, and if its legacy in most casual listeners' minds is just
"Sweet Home Alabama"
and the ubiquitous
"Free Bird,"
that's not a bad legacy to have, really.
's story is also a gothic Southern tragedy, haunted by fatal plane crashes and death, and if the 21st century version of the band (current membership includes ex-
Blackfoot
guitarist
Rickey Medlocke
, drummer
Michael Cartellone
, vocalist
Johnny Van Zant
, and guitarist
Gary Rossington
, who is the only member left from the original version of
) seems more like a facsimile than a continuation, one could chalk it up to pure attrition. So what to make of
God & Guns
, the group's new album from
Roadrunner Records
? It certainly sounds like
, maybe with a little more contemporary Nashville on board, and there's plenty of that Southern redneck rocker attitude on display, but what's missing, unfortunately, is compassion and heart, two qualities that were the secret ingredients in
's singing.
Johnny
sounds like him, sure, but where
Ronnie
came across slightly disappointed, wounded, and -- God forbid -- regretful underneath his swagger,
comes across like an archetypal Southern redneck convinced that America is all about guns and God -- one assumes
would wonder if those two things were ever a good idea to mix together. The lead single from this set,
"Still Unbroken,"
is a decent song, but unfortunately that's about it, although the album has a big, full feel. There just aren't many songs, really, to go with that fullness (
was produced by
Bob Marlette
) --
"Southern Ways"
has a certain charm, maybe because it's essentially a slowed-down rewrite of
with the same riff as an anchor, and
"Floyd"
has some ragged atmosphere going for it, but most of the songs here are far from memorable. It ends up feeling like an album that stomps and roars and sounds like
but somehow just isn't the same -- maybe because it isn't. ~ Steve Leggett