Joe-Joe’s sandwich cookies are Trader Joe’s classics. Over the years, we’ve developed limited-edition versions to celebrate different seasons and flavors (see: new Pumpkin Spiced Joe-Joe’s) In the interest of full transparency, we’ve had a few minor misses over the years, but when a Joe-Joe hits, longevity is often the result. Case in point: Trader Joe’s Halloween Joe-Joe’s, a holiday favorite for 10 years and counting!

Think of our Halloween Joe-Joe’s as regular Joe-Joe’s wearing a Halloween costume. They’re the same chocolate and vanilla crème sandwich cookies you know and love, but we’ve added annatto to the crème to give it a bright orange hue and “carved” the cocoa-flavored biscuits to look like jack-o-lanterns. No need to fear, though—these pumpkins are smiling, and they’ll make you do the same with every bite.