Will Scott and Katie's love of God and each other be enough to prevent a desperate man from making an irrevocable mistake? When Katie Bender returns home from her Rumspringa with a teaching certificate, a dream to teach the young scholars of her community, and an Englisher boyfriend to boot, her small Amish community is shocked at the young woman's audacity. Scott might be a good man, and he's certainly interested in marrying Katie, but will love be enough for him to set aside his Englisher life and his dreams of becoming a police officer? And even if he does follow through, will the community--and Katie's mamm--give him a chance? And when a terrifying, life or death situation sweeps up Katie and the young scholars she's grown to love, will Scott and Katie's love of God and each other be enough to prevent a desperate man from making an irrevocable mistake?