The best compliment that can be paid to
Nouvelle Vague
's self-titled debut album: it isn't as arch and smirking as a collection of
bossa nova
versions of
new wave
classics by fetching French and Brazilian chanteuses would suggest. Based on the concept alone,
seems similar to the work of jokesters like
the Mike Flowers Pops
or
Richard Cheese and Lounge Against the Machine
, but though the album is definitely playful, it works on a sincere level enough of the time to be more than just a goof. In fact,
's best moments are a tribute to how well written the words and melodies of these songs are; that they can withstand, and even thrive in, such different arrangements is no small feat. Smooth, smoky
ballads
, such as the opening track,
"Love Will Tear Us Apart,"
provide many of the album's highlights.
The Cure
's
"A Forest"
gets a tropical twist, complete with jungle sound effects, while
the Sisters of Mercy
"Marian"
remains as dark as ever but is now much more delicate -- call it gotha nova. On the other hand, the cover of
the Dead Kennedys
'
"Too Drunk to Fuck"
is a giggly, sassy, mischievous standout that bears virtually no resemblance to the original. Likewise, the serpentine version of
Killing Joke
"Psyche"
is radically different from the original, nor does it quite fit in with the rest of
's bright, breezy feeling, but its spooky vibe makes it one of the album's most interesting tracks. Two of the best covers come from a couple of the least well-known bands on the collection:
Tuxedomoon
"In a Manner of Speaking"
is transformed into a gorgeous, completely convincing
torch song
, and
Josef K
"Sorry for Laughing"
closes the album on a sweetly languid note. Not all of
is this inspired -- the version of
Depeche Mode
"Just Can't Get Enough"
is overly fussy, and while the covers of songs like
"I Melt With You"
and
"Making Plans for Nigel"
are nice enough, they don't have the spark of the album's best moments. But even at its worst,
is still pleasantly witty background music. This unlikely, but mostly happy, marriage of
will probably disappoint or displease purists who believe that every version of
"Love Will Tear Us Apart"
should have the brooding intensity of the original, but everyone else can enjoy the album's playful elegance. ~ Heather Phares