In the early days of the popular music industry, several Irish tenors -- or, at least, tenors of Irish descent who were born in or moved to the United States -- enjoyed considerable success with sentimental patriotic/nationalistic songs, and romantic tunes with Irish themes. Here are 21 such recordings, done between 1921 and 1953 by seven different artists,
Morton Downey
(father of talk show host
Morton Downey, Jr.
) and
John McCormack
being the most renowned. While these singers sometimes recorded songs with Irish
traditional folk
origins, this isn't
folk
music by any stretch of the imagination. Instead, it consists of various combinations of
Irish folk
music,
Tin Pan Alley
pop
, and
vaudeville
, with some operatic influence, cinematic
soundtrack
flavor, and military
march
rhythms for good measure. As such, the arrangements will feel dated to many listeners, and the vocal delivery far more sentimental than anyone would deliver with a straight face nowadays. Still, the singers do have a supple power, and skillfully tap into the archetypal mixture of unabashedly dramatic merriment and melancholy that many associate with Irish music (and culture). It's a highly commercialized form of Irish authenticity, but one that carries considerable idiosyncratically Irish character nonetheless. ~ Richie Unterberger