The last of the Jameson sisters, Penelope, operates a mail-order bride agency with her sister, Abigail, in Yerington, Nevada, matching ranchers with women from back east. She has sworn off love after her beau, Jake, in Ohio jilted her, but how can a matchmaker stay focused when facing down a handsome rancher? Mysterious rancher Morgan Henning is new to the Yerington area but is ready to get married, and sending for a mail-order bride seems like a great idea. That is until he meets Penelope, the matchmaker. Does he still want a mail-order bride, or is Penelope the woman he's been looking for?