Grace is a middle aged Amish woman who has given up hope of finding true love until she meets Mason, a widowed minister who is coming to replace Amos. Amos has always been a father figure to Grace and he thinks there is something off about Mason...something he can't put his finger on...But Grace and Mason soon develop romantic feelings for one another. When Amos finds out about Mason's past, he has a decision to make...Intervene on Grace's behalf or let her possibly get her heart broken...But what if Mason really is a changed man?