Hard to believe, but 's 2008 is the first CD compilation of recordings -- a disservice to a singer responsible for one of the great slow dance singles of the rock & roll era, As rock & roll as that may be -- revived it for his post- oldies fantasia and had a hit with it too -- the silken sighs in its sound hint that was an uptown crooner, a suspicion borne out by this lengthy compilation. walked the fine, sometimes imperceptible, line between uptown R&B and stiff, starched pop, always easing into a song, never attacking it. Unlike some '50s crooners, he wasn't hammy, he was friendly, and that goes a long way when the material gets syrupy or corny, as it often did during the course of his recordings, chronicled here in their entirety, complete with nine unreleased tracks (two being alternates of and ). Sometimes, he was undone by the sheer inanity of the material -- neither or could have given a trifle like or the cutesy bop a shred of listenability -- but he often kept his dignity even at moments like this. was at his best when the arrangements weren't quite so straitjacketed: of course, there's which struck the perfect balance between pop and R&B, but he comes close to that same feel on has a good rolling gait, there's a nice, light lazy version of is good-natured pop-R&B, is a sweet, skipping heartbroken plea, and he does a good version of that's strikingly stripped-down compared to the rest of his work, veering close to doo wop. Apart from that, the selections on can get a little syrupy, but ' voice is always winning and, for certain tastes, the oversized strings, harmonies, and soft melodies are all enjoyable even if they're admittedly generic. At the very least, it's good to have his work finally documented on a collection as generous and well-produced as this. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine