Released in conjunction with
Billy Joel
's grand experiment with
classical
music,
The Essential Billy Joel
was a welcome reminder of
's way with a
pop
song, improving on the previous
Greatest Hits, Vol. 1 & 2
by extending into the '90s and delving deeper into his catalog. There were some casualties along the way -- it's easy for a fan to carp about the absence of personal favorites like
"She's Right on Time"
or
"Travelin' Prayer,"
and it may even make some sense that
"You're Only Human (Second Wind)"
"Shameless"
didn't make the cut, but it's mind-boggling that
"Scenes From an Italian Restaurant"
isn't here (we won't mention that the
pieces that end the record, no matter how surprisingly good they are, are as out of place as
Attila
would have been) -- but for the most part, this has every one of
Joel
's heavy-hitters, and his craftsmanship, both as a songsmith and record maker, has never shone brighter. The biggest fault is that there is a notable drop-off in quality after 1986's
The Bridge
(which ends midway through disc two), but even so, this is as good a distillation of
's talents imaginable. In fact, as the first disc unfurls, even cynics may wonder why he's been dogged by the critics, since
singer/songwriter
doesn't come better than
"Say Goodbye to Hollywood,"
"New York State of Mind,"
"Only the Good Die Young,"
"My Life,"
"It's Still Rock and Roll to Me,"
"Don't Ask Me Why,"
"Allentown,"
and their seven companions. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine