Annabelle and her dad plan to come to the city to watch Arnie play in a soccer game, and the kids get their hopes up that their mom and dad will reconcile following their divorce announcement. But when Annabelle and Dad arrive in the city, the kids are shocked and angry to learn that both their parents are interested in dating other people. Is there any chance that the siblings' deepest wish—for their family to reunite—could still come true?