Phoebe Andrews has been running from her past for the last five years-hiding in her busy life in the big city, and avoiding going home at all costs. Avoiding seeing again. The first guy to break her heart. When her family begs her to come home for Christmas, Phoebe can't say no. Maybe going home, and facing her past, will help fill the empty hole in her heart. Afterall, there's nothing like a few holiday games to help spark her love for the season again. Spencer Larson has been keeping a secret for the last five years. A secret that drove the girl who stole his heart out of his life. He never expected to see her again, so when Phoebe comes back home for the holidays, he feels like he's been given a second chance. He loved the girl she was back then, but he quickly realizes that she's not that girl anymore, and he might just love this version of her even more. Can he keep his secret and still find a way to win her heart? When their families surprise them by hosting their old childhood contest; The Mistletoe Feud, Phoebe and Spencer are forced to work together in order to win the coveted Mistletoe Crown. She'll stop at nothing to win it for herself, and he'll do whatever it takes to make sure she gets it. Five years apart. Five tasks await them. Five opportunities to win. Five days of forced proximity. Five chances to fall in love again. Will their mutual pining and love for the game be enough to win this year, or will the secrets of the past continue to tear them apart?