After 10 years as one of the MVPs of the TJ’s cheese case, one might think that our Unexpected Cheddar’s ability to surprise would have waned, somewhat. Then Trader Joe’s Unexpected Cheddar Chicken Sausage came along. Which isn’t to say that it’s necessarily shocking that cheese and chicken go well together, of course, but the degree to which this Parmesan-like Cheddar pairs with the flavor of savory-seasoned, lightly smoked chicken, sweet bits of caramelized onions and red pepper, and the satisfying snap of a natural pork casing? That’s nothing short of astonishing.

Fully cooked and ready to reheat, Trader Joe’s Unexpected Cheddar Chicken Sausages can be grilled, steamed, or pan-fried, and serve beautifully on a toasty, buttery bun—especially when adorned with Whole Grain Dijon Mustard or Organic Sweet Pickle Relish. They’re also delicious when sliced into rounds, sautéed, and mixed into hearty soups, breakfast hashes, and creamy pastas dishes. And if you’re feeling really spontaneous, or extra cheesy (or both), it’s especially tasty when served hot with a sprinkling of melty Shredded Unexpected Cheddar on top.