Trouble often comes in threes. It's no different at the Black Horse Campground. On his first day as detective with the Bonney Police Department, J.D. Wilder finds three cold case files on his desk – three women who disappeared over a fifteen year period. It seems no one has ever properly investigated them. Then a woman from his past arrives to ask for his help. Again. The timing couldn't be worse, since he's finally about to ask Corrie on a date. ButCorrie also has a visitor from her past show up. And Sheriff Rick Sutton has his hands full dodging his ex-wife, Meghan, who insists on digging up a painful memory. When three bodies are discovered that prove the missing women were murdered, J.D.'s investigation reveals that all of their visitors have some connection to the victims. But which one of them killed three women? And will there be a fourth victim