Brilliant baker Rosie Hart is busier than ever as she prepares for Airlie Falls's famed Valentine's Day Farmers and Craft Market. The last thing she needs as she races to frost her cashew nut cakes is the mysterious appearance of a dead body found on her new fiancé, Jonah's, property. To add icing to the cupcake, another long-dead body is found buried underneath it. For goodness bakes! Rosie vows to leave the investigating to the sheriff this time—she has enough to juggle with her baking business and her nonagenarian friends who are entranced by a new seniors dating app. But when rumors begin affecting Jonah's construction business, enough is enough. Getting answers will mean retracing the unexplained disappearance of a woman ten years earlier—a woman who had a dalliance with a now-famous actor and is supposedly speaking through a clairvoyant. Can Rosie solve the case in time to ensure this Valentine's Day is remembered for all the right reasons?