Due to the tragic loss of her twin brother Ethan and his wife Grace, Nora is left to grieve while she cares for their five-year-old daughter Hailey. Sarah, Peyton, and Gina along with the rest of Cherrywood rally around them. The situation is made more complicated when Logan, Sarah's brother, Ethan's best friend, and Nora's lifelong crush, returns after he disappeared over three years ago. Nora and Logan were both left custody of Hailey. It seems the very tragedy that forced them together may be the very thing to finally ignite a spark between them. However, when Nora learns where Logan has been all this time it may very well tear them apart.