Baking cupcakes for the science department bake-off shouldn't strike fear into the heart of chemistry teacher Noah, but his previous record hasn't exactly been glowing. In an attempt to stave off another year in last place, Noah turns to the one man who might be able to help him: his best friend's older brother, Spencer. Noah's had a crush on the vibrant and sporty footballer turned baker for years, but the chances of anything happening between them are slim to none. Spencer is caring, funny, gorgeous... and totally straight. Spencer has never thought about dating men before, but after watching Noah lick buttercream off a whisk he's suddenly realising he's not as straight as previously thought. Revelations about his sexuality are one thing, but his footballing past being dragged into the present is another and Spencer isn't sure which is more stressful. But he's sure about one thing: he wants Noah in his life. Now all they have to do is figure out how to make their wishes come true.