Back again for its eleventh year as part of our holiday lineup, each distinctively designed box of Trader Joe’s Taste Test of Caramels contains twelve square caramels covered in luscious dark chocolate. Each is hand-decorated with a unique design that may hint at the fascinating flavors that lie within. This year—joining returning favorites Double Espresso, Fig & Honey, Hot Chili, and Maple—you’ll find eight brand new flavors: Caramel Mousse, Salted Torte, Gingerbread, Pear & Cinnamon, Sea Salt, Passion Fruit, Crème Brûlée, and Salted Lavender. Feeling adventurous? Throw caution to the wind and try them without first matching them to the map you’ll find on the underside of the box—there’s a great deal of fun to be had in figuring out the flavors on your own.

Give our updated-for-2023 Taste Test of Caramels as a gift and grab an extra for yourself. Better yet, have a chocolate-caramel tasting party! Buy a few boxes and invite a bunch of buddies, enjoying great company and delicious candy.