Ten years after Kellan Sutherland is nearly murdered, his nightmare returns when his attacker is unexpectedly released from jail. Sheriff Alexander Romano is determined to protect the man he loves, even if he has to prove himself to Kellan to do it. Garrett Lennox is finding it more and more difficult to keep his attraction to star athlete Ozborne Hunter a secret. Plans for their 'first time' go horribly wrong, leaving Oz badly injured. After the assault, Oz suddenly disappears and Garrett is devastated. He is determined not to give up the man he loves and vows to find him. Otto Becham's past forces him to keep everyone at an emotional distance. That is, until Prescott Worthington tempts Otto into giving in to his attraction. Just when Prescott thinks he has a chance at earning Otto's trust, Otto's past returns, bringing his worst nightmares to life...