Anjuli, Blair, Charlie, and Olivia are finishing a summer that the girls will never forget. After they kill off the four dark horsemen, the girls are ready to start a normal school year. Anjuli and Blair are preparing for their senior year. Charlie and Olivia are starting school in a new state. Charlie is starting at a new school where no one knows her past, minus her circle. However, the school year becomes something that the four never saw coming. A new villain comes into play, and their friendship is tested. Their GPA isn't the only thing at risk; their secrets and lives are also at risk.