These creepy cookies are so finger-licking-good, it'll be hard to keep your hands off them. They're scratch-baked from buttery vanilla sugar cookies with crunchy roasted almond nails and crimson icing. Point the way to the dessert table and let guests savor them from nail to nub.

• Includes ten 1" x 5" shortbread cookies (7 oz. total).
• Shipped fresh.